Polarizing methods, superior results found at NYC's largest charter school network

NEW YORK » At most schools, if a child is flailing academically, it is treated as a private matter.

But at Success Academy Harlem 4, one boy's struggles were there for all to see: On two colored charts in the hallway, where the students' performance on weekly spelling and math quizzes was tracked, his name was at the bottom, in a red zone denoting that he was below grade level.

The boy, a fourth-grader, had been in the red zone for months. His teacher, Kristin Jones, 23, had held meetings with his mother, where the teacher spread out all the weekly class newsletters from the year, in which the charts were reproduced. If he studied, he could pass the spelling quizzes, Jones said — he just was not trying. But the boy got increasingly frustrated, and some weeks Jones had to stop herself from looking over his shoulder during the quizzes so she would not get upset by his continued mistakes.

Then, one Friday in December, she peeked at his paper, and a smile spread over her face. After he handed in his quiz, she announced to the class that he had gotten a 90. "I might start crying right now," she said, only half-joking. "I've got to call your mom."

In its devotion to accountability, Success Academy, New York City's polarizing charter school network, may have no peer.

Though it serves primarily poor, mostly black and Hispanic students, Success is a testing dynamo, outscoring schools in many wealthy suburbs, let alone their urban counterparts. In New York City last year, 29 percent of public school students passed the state reading tests, and 35 percent passed the math tests. At Success schools, the corresponding percentages were 64 and 94 percent.

Those kinds of numbers have helped Success, led by Eva S. Moskowitz, expand to become the city's largest charter network. By next year Moskowitz, known for her attention-grabbing rallies and skirmishes with the teachers' union and Mayor Bill de Blasio, will have 43 schools; a proposal by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo could get her closer to her goal of 100. That would give Success more schools than Buffalo, the state's second-largest district.

In a rare look inside the network, including visits to several schools and interviews with dozens of current and former employees, The New York Times chronicled a system driven by the relentless pursuit of better results, one that can be exhilarating for teachers and students who keep up with its demands and agonizing for those who do not.

Rules are explicit and expectations precise. Students must sit with hands clasped and eyes following the speaker; reading passages must be neatly annotated with a main idea.

Incentives are offered, such as candy for good behavior, and Nerf guns and basketballs for high scores on practice tests. For those deemed not trying hard enough, there is "effort academy," which is part detention, part study hall.

see more http://www.staradvertiser.com/news/nyt/19040101_Polarizing_methods_superior_results_found_at_NYCs_largest_charter_school_network.html?id=298862751